diff --git a/src/OpenTheBox/Program.cs b/src/OpenTheBox/Program.cs
index f325ea3..15ab677 100644
--- a/src/OpenTheBox/Program.cs
+++ b/src/OpenTheBox/Program.cs
@@ -212,13 +212,19 @@ public static class Program
             return;
         }
 
-        var boxNames = boxes.Select(b => GetLocalizedName(b.DefinitionId)).ToList();
+        // Group boxes by type so the list isn't bloated with duplicates
+        var grouped = boxes.GroupBy(b => b.DefinitionId).ToList();
+        var boxNames = grouped.Select(g =>
+        {
+            var name = GetLocalizedName(g.Key);
+            return g.Count() > 1 ? $"{name} (x{g.Count()})" : name;
+        }).ToList();
         boxNames.Add(_loc.Get("menu.back"));
 
         int choice = _renderer.ShowSelection(_loc.Get("prompt.choose_box"), boxNames);
-        if (choice >= boxes.Count) return;
+        if (choice >= grouped.Count) return;
 
-        var boxInstance = boxes[choice];
+        var boxInstance = grouped[choice].First();
 
         var openAction = new OpenBoxAction(boxInstance.Id)
         {
@@ -322,8 +328,9 @@ public static class Program
             {
                 var def = _registry.GetItem(g.Key);
                 var bDef = def is null ? _registry.GetBox(g.Key) : null;
+                var baseName = GetLocalizedName(g.Key);
                 return (
-                    name: GetLocalizedName(g.Key),
+                    name: g.Count() > 1 ? $"{baseName} (x{g.Count()})" : baseName,
                     rarity: (def?.Rarity ?? bDef?.Rarity ?? ItemRarity.Common).ToString(),
                     category: (def?.Category ?? ItemCategory.Box).ToString()
                 );